~L2 WAR~

J.Q

i see some blood again in L2
not yet cease fire ?

vikings

We actually had a Defensive win today...  a wave of 976k all dead....

mattao

U23 FTW.................

Gabefu / LordGa

Gogogogo U23!!!!

rebourcet

Looking forward for a 3M wave BR from U24

avita

show BR please

LieFeng

they are not trustworthy . they are damn traitors .

curse you MALDIVES .

WhitePrincess

now u23 has a reason to really KILL those traitors

521829511@faceb

who's warring against whom?  U server wars or simply league wars?

mattao

8 wonders are no more.

cheewah325

where is my hero? I can see from the main list but not in the city, where my hero go??

bao

There is a question that I had been dying to ask. Not sure whether Mod GeorgeBush can help to confirm/clarify.

Question:
Will troops from the player's sub-cities receive the bonuses (EO/nobility/ironwall, etc) of the player or only troops in the city being attack would receive those bonuses?

I'm not sure why everybody is assuming that troops from the sub-cities of the player would receive those bonuses, as I also have that assumption until I saw my losses in my previous merger war.

If troops from sub-cities won't receive those bonus, everybody can stop building defense troops in sub-cities, as they fare much worse than support from other players with hero. (They are considered as support troops without hero!) Though you may want to consider sending them to support other players with a good ironwall hero, at least they would fare better than supporting your own city...

Hope to have an answer to that as it would affects how players build troops/prepare for merger.
Thanks.

Liauw

Bao - the troops from you own sub-cities defending your other city, YES, you'll get the bonuses.

vikings

LieFeng replied at 1-2-2013 21:55
they are not trustworthy . they are damn traitors .

curse you MALDIVES .

taking care of it... we had proof of there treachery.... so enuff talk..

bao

Liauw replied at 2-2-2013 10:19
Bao - the troops from you own sub-cities defending your other city, YES, you'll get the bonuses.

Hi Liauw, thanks for replying, but are you sure of it? I was hoping admin/moderator can confirm it, cos it doesn't seem to be so...

I know someone had probably tested it long ago, that's why everybody (including me) thought you would get the bonuses, but did anybody else tested it with the latest version?

Did the technicians changed it/missed out on it during the upgrade to new version? Or was it even meant to be the case?

bao

nasris_light replied at 2-2-2013 12:48
Troops sent from your own accounts sub cities will receive the bonus that is supplied by the hero' ...

Hi nasris, thanks for the answer, but I'm really looking and hoping for confirmation from admin/moderator rather than fellow players. I really held the same view as you for more than 2 years, that's why I build a lot of defenders before my last merge.

I hope you understand where I'm coming from, if what I'm suspecting is true, it will explain why ~Zeus~'s 1.8mil own troops is so weak against the attack, cos they would be considered 'naked troops' (troops without any bonuses). If that's considered a bug, its probably a bug across all merger servers with the new merger rules...

I won't bug on this issue in this thread anymore, won't want to be considered hijacking the thread. But still hoping for answer from GB or Raf.

To fellow players, please please hold on to your views and continue to build defense troops, just don't be too disappointed when you see the results of your hard work in your next merger...

bao

nasris_light replied at 5-2-2013 00:22
Bao my only logical confirmation for this stance is that if you send a hero from the sub city whic ...

Sorry to continue hijacking this thread, but just want to say that we all come from different background and what might sound logical to one party might not sound logical to another party, only facts can give confirmation.

For this case, I agree with you on "there is no possible way to give those sub city troops a bonus with a separate hero". So could the programmer had taken the easy way out and simply don't give the sub city troops hero bonus?

I'm not a programmer, so I'm not sure how tough or easy it is to program the following scenarios:

Scenario 1 (Sub-city troops get hero bonus)
1a. Check supporting troops for sub-city troops
1b. If sub-city troops, check for hero in the city being attacked and add the hero bonus to the troops.
1c. If not sub-city troops, check for hero.
1d. If got hero, program bonus for the troop, if no hero, no bonus for troops.

Scenario 2. (Sub-city troops do not get hero bonus)
2a. Check supporting troops for hero.
2b. If got hero, program bonus for the troop, if no hero, no bonus for troops.

Could the programmer had missed out the check for sub-city troops? Nobody knows except the programmer.
We can say "I think..." "you think..." but then who confirm?
Maybe only the programmer can confirm? And other than the mod/admin here, I'm not sure who else can check with the programmer directly to get a confirmed answer.

Naris, if you have the time and means, do try to do some tests. You might be surprised with the results.

~Yo~

we are having everything except BR in this sub-forum